2 Marzo, 2024

Roberto’s work will have a long legacy

Tempo di lettura: 4 minuti

Roberto Camagni certainly has made a positive and lasting contribution to shaping ESPON and left his mark on European territorial research. He also played a significant role in promoting a territorial dimension in European cohesion policy.

Roberto joined the ESPON family in its early days and has been an active member and supporter until his last days.

As many others we will certainly miss him, and his death is a great loss for the community, both in personal and professional terms. However, he will be with us even in future, thanks to the great legacy he has left in the field.

Roberto made sure that ESPON and European territorial research advanced in understanding complex developments and befriended macroeconomic modelling. In doing so, he also ensured that the research results do not just confirm general perceptions, but also lead to debate whether widely accepted assumptions actually are true. His response to an EU Commission official questioning a map Roberto presented will stay legendary: “That the results are counterintuitive shows that the model works.”

More precisely Roberto was among the key persons pushing forward the idea of territorial impact assessment and developing approaches to quantify territorial impacts of EU policies. This involved among others his conceptualisation of territorial cohesion, as well as models such as ESPON TEQUILA and later on ESPON TEQUILA SIP.

Like many others also Roberto engaged in defining and operationalising “territorial cohesion”. Unlike many others, he came up with a clear and measurable definition of this fuzzy concept. This definition puts the focus on the concept of territorial capital, bringing together a wide range of potential assets for regional growth, by underlining the economic nature of each of them.

The ESPON TEQUILA methodology is widely recognised as one of the most comprehensive methodologies covering the various dimensions and considering a wide range of components of his territorial cohesion concept. Results are based on quantitative assessments of forecast models performed by external experts and expert judgements collected via interviews. With ESPON TEQUILA SIP this was later on developed into an interactive simulation package. This pioneering work by Roberto and his team largely inspired the work and development of the methodology used for Territorial Impact Assessments today by the European Committee of the Regions and even within the European Commission.

The progress made builds clearly on the thinking and the work he and his team have developed in the context of the macro-econometric regional growth forecasting model Macroeconomic, Sectoral, Social and Territorial (MASST). Referring to the MASST model, another good friend, Andreu Ulied, never got tired of noting, that the modelling by Roberto and his team projected the impacts of the 2008 financial crisis much more accurately than those of many other big players in the field.

As said, apart from being very active and innovative in the research field, Roberto also bridged to the policy arena. Way back he supported the focus on spatial development in the European policy context within the then Committee for Spatial Development (CSD) that elaborated a European Spatial Development Perspective (ESDP). Later he followed and participated in debates around the Territorial Agendas that followed.

He was always very active expressing his opinions and views in debates, both with scientific colleagues and with policy makers in ESPON seminars. He also promoted the expanding European evidence at European meetings as well as in the Italian context. As examples of the latter, he was once engaged as special advisor during an Italian EU Presidency, and he was involved in understanding the national relevance of ESPON results looking upon the Italian territory in its European context which resulted in a report informing policy makers and the Italian public.    

In hindsight, ESPON would not have been the same without Roberto, and his valuable contributions. As well, his efforts promoting science and evidence with a European territorial dimension in the political context deserves sincere appreciation as well.

Roberto’s intellectual capacity, nice personality and gentle approach to other people will always be remembered. He was a real Italian gentleman that deserves a lot of credit for the work he has done for ESPON and for Europe.

We are sure that his legacy will last for a long time.

Articoli correlati

Qualità dei beni, produttività ed il ruolo della città

Roberto Camagni ha contribuito a rispondere a due grandi paradossi della letteratura economica: il “paradosso di Solow” e il "paradosso di Baumol". Per il primo, in particolare, suggerisce che la debole associazione empirica tra progresso tecnologico e variazione della produttività sia legata al fatto che quest’ultima cattura soltanto una parte dell’effetto dell’innovazione sulla competitività dei sistemi economici. Inoltre, ha dimostrato come l'innovazione tecnologica possa diversificare i prodotti e ampliare il mercato, mantenendo il dominio delle città.

L’economia urbana in cinque principi

Uno dei maggiori lasciti di Roberto Camagni è il suo manuale di Economia Urbana. Camagni si focalizza non tanto sui modelli teorici fondamentali dell’analisi urbana, quanto sui principi economici rinvenibili a monte di essi, ma di rado esplicitati. Lo scopo è costruire una cultura dei fondamenti diffusa e condivisa, dove impiega l’analisi economica come un metodo volto a integrare rappresentazioni nate in discipline differenti, identificando un numero limitato di principi genetici del complesso fenomeno urbano: agglomerazione, accessibilità, interazione, gerarchia, competitività.

Economie di agglomerazione: oltre la dimensione urbana

Roberto si concentra sulle economie di agglomerazione nelle città e critica la visione meccanicistica che considera solo dimensioni e densità come fattori determinanti. Propone un modello chiamato SOUDY che considera la crescita della città legata alla sua capacità di innovare nelle funzioni che svolge. Inoltre, ha una visione critica del rapporto città-campagna dove discute il ruolo predatorio della città nei confronti della campagna.

La teoria delle reti di città

La ricerca di Roberto Camagni sulle reti di città ha ridefinito prospettive analitiche nel ciclo di vita urbano, rivelando strutture reticolari latenti o già formate con esternalità estese. Ha cambiato l'immagine del Nord Italia e dimostrato i vantaggi della cooperazione tra sistemi urbani per ridurre i costi della concorrenza. Ha enfatizzato l'importanza di politiche territoriali efficaci per garantire l'efficienza e la divisione del lavoro nelle reti urbane.

Il valore conteso. La rendita immobiliare tra economia e urbanistica

A una elaborata lettura teorica della rendita, Roberto Camagni ha sempre affiancato una riflessione sugli strumenti che ne consentono la restituzione alla comunità. Il confronto sugli strumenti per la cattura dei plusvalori immobiliari - perequazione, accordi e diritti edificatori - è stata occasione per riflettere su opportunità e limiti di una nuova stagione di dialogo tra economia e urbanistica.